[Air-L] The difficult conversation we don't seem to be having

[Ayelet Baram-Tsabari]

Hello Sky,
While I appreciate your contribution to the discussion, here in Israel, we do not believe in the harassment of individuals during academic discussions.
I view this discussion as important, but if you are unable to communicate in a professional manner, might I suggest that you have someone else review your emails before you send them?
I also ask those involved in the discussion to look up the definition of ‘genocide’ before they use the term and to review the actions of their own governments to previous terror attacks.
Finally, I suggest that Europeans who live in glass houses on Aboriginal land would be a little less enthusiastic about throwing stones.
Best,
Prof. Ayelet Baram-Tsabari

-----Original Message-----
From: Air-L <air-l-bounces at listserv.aoir.org> On Behalf Of Sky Croeser via Air-L
Sent: Tuesday, 23 January 2024 16:21
To: Air-L <air-l at listserv.aoir.org>
Subject: Re: [Air-L] The difficult conversation we don't seem to be having

Several of our colleagues in Israel have written to this list about the loss of acquaintances, friends, students, and colleagues. They have asked that their grief and fear not be forgotten. I send my condolences to those who have experienced loss and trauma.

I would like to take a moment to note that we have not had Palestinian colleagues send similar emails to the list. I want to take a moment to make this visible.

It is not because we have no Palestinian colleagues. Since opening this conversation, I have had private emails from Palestinian academics on this list who have said they've felt forgotten and abandoned by their academic communities. One wrote (asking me to share it with name and details removed
- and I do hope that this will be allowed through to the main list, as it is one of the few messages from a Palestinian colleague about their
experiences):

"*Thank you for your courage in sending such an email. As a Palestinian, it made me tear up, as I finally see my people being acknowledged by one of several academic communities I am part of, which have been silent.*

*I am, of course, a very privileged Palestinian as I currently live [overseas], but my whole family and friends are in Palestine, and I do travel back home. I don’t even dare to post publicly in this forum, as I have a great fear for my safety and my family’s safety.*

*Please look up [Technion] and how deeply it’s interlinked with the Israeli military and apartheid, probably also developing the face recognition technology that the Israeli occupation military used last summer in the West Bank to scan [the faces of people who I know] and put them in their
database.*

*People like Ayelet who live across the wall of apartheid with all the privileges and power she has are exactly why we need to have these tough and rightful conversations. In her recent email she is also supporting the collective punishment of millions of Palestinians and depriving them from basic necessities like fuel that are essential to run hospitals that are providing medical aid to hundreds of thousands of displaced and injured Palestinian people. * *It demonstrates that after 75 years of oppression and occupation, and 105 days of non-stop ethnic cleansing and genocide, change will never come from within Israeli society, but rather from outside pressure.*

*Feel free to repost my message, but please remove my email and information as this will pose great risk for my safety." *Further information on Technion which this colleague refers to is available here <https://protect.checkpoint.com/v2/___https://bdsmovement.net/news/mcgill-and-concordia-must-boycott-technion___.YzJlOnRlY2huaW9uOmM6bzpmNTBkNzQzNWRlMzM4ZTlmM2Y4MGYyYTEwNDc4MWUyNzo2OjU2YjE6OWNjYjM4NGVmNzQ5ZTZjMDgzZDM3NzU3MzgyY2FhYzlmOThjY2RiZTM2YjFkOTA1YmQ5MzI0YzMxNmEzYmVjZjpwOlQ>.

Do we have colleagues in Gaza who cannot reply to the mailing list to let us know of their grief, fears, and suffering in the way that others have? I don't know. *Did* we have colleagues in Gaza, 109 days ago, who we will now never hear from again? I don't know.

I understand and sympathise with Israeli colleagues who do not want us to forget their losses from October 7th 2023.

I also wonder if we have Palestinian colleagues who wish that they felt safe telling us about their losses not just since that date, but also in the years before it. If they would like to urge us, similarly, to see their pain and acknowledge it. I wonder if there are Palestinian colleagues who wish they could talk openly to us about the history of arrests of Palestinian students <https://protect.checkpoint.com/v2/___https://law4palestine.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/Law-for-Palestine-Report.-Israels-Arrest-Policy-against-Palestinian-University-Students-in-the-West-Bank-and-Israel-.pdf___.YzJlOnRlY2huaW9uOmM6bzpmNTBkNzQzNWRlMzM4ZTlmM2Y4MGYyYTEwNDc4MWUyNzo2OjI2ZDY6M2U0MTk5NjQwM2I3MTNiOTg5M2ZiMWM0N2ZkNjA1ZWRlYzVkYWZkYjhjYWEzMzg0ZjY3NzY1YjhmZWVhNDk4ZjpwOlQ>.
Or about the delays and chaos they face in their own teaching. Personal stories of students, colleagues, and loved ones who have been killed or prevented from studying over the years.

We do not have those stories. I hope that none of us will allow ourselves to imagine it is because they do not exist. And I hope that we will think deeply about why it is that we do not get to read any of them.
_______________________________________________
The Air-L at listserv.aoir.org mailing list is provided by the Association of Internet Researchers https://protect.checkpoint.com/v2/___http://aoir.org___.YzJlOnRlY2huaW9uOmM6bzpmNTBkNzQzNWRlMzM4ZTlmM2Y4MGYyYTEwNDc4MWUyNzo2OjllMjc6MDYzZDk3N2JiNWU2YmE3ZjM1NzRlZmFkMGM5NGQwZTg1Yjg1MWI3NzJhODI0MmJhZjBmNWMzZmE4YTAyMzIzMTpwOlQ
Subscribe, change options or unsubscribe at: https://protect.checkpoint.com/v2/___http://listserv.aoir.org/listinfo.cgi/air-l-aoir.org___.YzJlOnRlY2huaW9uOmM6bzpmNTBkNzQzNWRlMzM4ZTlmM2Y4MGYyYTEwNDc4MWUyNzo2OmM4YWE6ZjQxMTYxMjc4ZTQ0MDJhMjYyYmQzODE1N2JlZDAxZWQ5MTAyMGNjMzM3YzZmYTljYTNmNzUyMDUxMTY0ZmNmZjpwOlQ

Join the Association of Internet Researchers:
https://protect.checkpoint.com/v2/___http://www.aoir.org/___.YzJlOnRlY2huaW9uOmM6bzpmNTBkNzQzNWRlMzM4ZTlmM2Y4MGYyYTEwNDc4MWUyNzo2OjAxNDg6OGJlMWIwZTQwMWQyYzNiNDgzN2JmMTJhMjIyYTRkNWQyODJhNjExYmIxNDgwZWUyZDViZThhMjVhZWIyMjYxZDpwOlQ
External e-mail, be judicious when opening attachments or links